« U.K. Genealogy Skypecast and "Open Topic" Skypecast | Main | Free Tuition at Northwestern University Thanks to Your Ancestry »

September 14, 2006

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

jtaubman

Following this review I ordered a copy of this program. It did not live up to my expectations though.

I would recommend not buying this for UK research, it simply does not understand obvious things like Guernsey is a Channel Island, but it knows that Jersey is one. It does not understand the Isle of Man, anyone born there ends up coming from the Isle of Man in Scotland, and even if you have a town, the gazetter does not know any of them. The ploting reguarly plots seaside places in the sea. There is currently no support for selecting people from your file to plot on the chart it simply does the whole file. This means locations where generations lived can have key locations missed because the red dots are too close together. It seems that adding places does not link them to the countries or countys they belong to. My own feeling this was a product released before it was ready in time to get it available for a show. Check out the support forum before ordering to make sure no one is having problems with the regions you want to use.

Mike More

The author probably has a vaild point with his UK locations. I don't have Guernsey or the Isle of Man but I did notice that Liverpool is located about 15 km offshore (some people may prefer it there). The US and Canadian locations seem to be very accurate, as might be expected.

The filtering feature does allow you to select the people to plot on your map. And when I added Gimli, Manitoba, Canada to my map, it plotted it. I did select from the gazatteer. Perhaps adding places not in the gazatteer would be a problem but I can't think of any that the gazatteer doesn't include.

I concur with not spending money on the program at this time. But let's blame it for real faults.

Stegemüller

Hi

I'm thinking of buying this programe, but does it support Danish maps?

David

My genealogical database is predominantly the UK, Europe, Australia and NZ and I agree with other criticisms of MMFT in relation to the gazetteer for these regions. I have experienced other major problems. 1: it is not possible to have MMFT and FTM for Windows both open the same datafile, so making corrections to FTM locations data is so tedious with starting and closing programs that it isn't worth doing. 2: with FTM "Facts" where the fields are type (e.g. "Occupation", date and "details or location", MMFT treats any text in the latter field as a location, and of course when it's an occupation (as it is for hundreds of my individuals for whom I have Occupation data) the text is placed in the Unknown Places list in MMFT. Placing these hundreds of Unknown Places texts in the Ignore List is very tedious, requiring 4 or 5 clicks, opening and closing and opening the Ignore List and doing a "Geo-Code update" every time.

In the MMFT user forum their "help" person has only so far said that problem 1: above is acknowledged and has suggested that it may be addressed in the future (time frame unspecified).

I have very recently asked if there are ways to address the 2: "text treated as location" problem or if not when there will be a fix but no reply yet.

I wish I had known about both problems before I purchased MMFT.

David

James Taylor

Hello Dick,

Just caught up with your comments on Map My Family Tree, including your remarks about your ancestor from Wessex, England. There is no such place as Wessex in England and hasn't been since the Middle Ages, well before Colonial days. It would probably have remained forgotten if it were not for its resurrection in Thomas Hardy's novels.

James Taylor
England

Dick Eastman

Thanks for the information about Wessex, James. My ancestor was born there in the late 1500s. What name would apply for those years?

- Dick Eastman

Mary Rogers

I have recently bought TMG - the master genealogist software - uk edition and this product is advertised as a companion product. Since the last comments have there been any enhancements to make it user friendly to UK users......90% of my usage is for UK ancestors

John Farmer

Plotting colonial information on modern maps is a real problem. It is important to visualize place data in its proper context. For example my Western PA ancestors were living on the frontier at the time not in the USA of today.

Sam Evans

Wessex consisted of much of the later counties of Gloucestershire, Oxfordshire, Hampshire, Wiltshire, Berkshire, Dorset and Somerset, so if the only information you have is the area Wessex, your ancestor's home could have been anywhere over almost half of southern England.

Peter Newcombe

In addition to Sam Evans note about Wessex, it also consisted of Devon which was conquered by the West Saxons (hence the name Wessex)in the 8th-9th century; and a last edition to the Wessex kingdom was Cornwall, which was conquered in the 9th-10th century. It all fell apart with the Norman invasion after 1066.

Carolyn E.

Software developers alert! THIS WOULD BE MY DREAM SOFTWARE: Take Anitmaps and extend it world-wide for historical accuracy and context. Add some limited GenLines historical facts (similar to what Peter did above) to provide context for why the borders changed over time. When possible provide the reason for the name of a location (as Peter did or say Cherry Valley, Ashtabula, OH is named such because it was settled by people from Cherry Valley, Otsego, NY but why was Cherry Valley NY called that? (I think because of the Cherry River but which came first the chicken or the egg)). What were the populations of the locations at that time? Use the visual display of Ancestry.com to make the output look very professional. Select the location of the entire db or a filter for a date range. See the migration of direct ancesters differently than extended ancestors (not just by surname). Google maps is fine for today, but not 350 year ago!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Receive FREE daily newsletter updates by email

  • Enter your email address


    Click here to see a typical e-mail message you will receive.

    I promise that:

    1. I will never sell, rent, or give away your address to any outside party, ever;
    2. I will never send you any unrequested e-mail, besides newsletter updates; and
    3. All unsubscribe requests are honored immediately, period.

My Photo

Search This Site for Past Articles

  • Loading

Meet Dick Eastman in Person

February 2010

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28            

Amazon Kindle

Offers

Blog powered by TypePad

Top Ten Most Popular Online Genealogy Magazines

Amazon Picks

Receive daily newsletter updates by email

  • Enter your Email


    Preview

    (Don't worry, I hate spam as much as you do and you will be able to UNSUBSCRIBE within seconds at any time!)